Academic Integrity
We ask you not to cheat, in any way, shape, or form. In return, we will
try our best to be fair about the amount of work we are giving you, in
the grading of that work, and in giving you a course grade. You can always
talk to us if you have any gripe or criticism about the course, and we
will attempt to respond to it immediately.
We mention various aspects of cheating in this course further below.
Why shouldn't you cheat? Society thrives and grows on trust and respect.
If that trust is broken, then chaos tends to enter in. This trust can
be on a small scale, such as simply trusting a bus driver to get you
to your destination (if the driver is drunk, you may be killed; you trust
that they are not drunk). Or it can be on a huge scale, such as the current
Middle East.
| |
Examples of Trust and no Trust
|
| In this course |
You trust us to teach you programming, with a reasonable amount of work on your part
and hopefully in an interesting way. You trust us to treat students equally, and not
to grade one person's work more or less leniently because we like or don't like them.
In turn, we trust you to do your work in a timely manner, without cheating.
|
| Taking a bus |
You trust that the driver is not drunk and will carefully drive you to your destination.
|
| Downloading music |
Musicians produce music and expect to get paid for its use, so that they can make a living.
They trust the copyright system. You violate that trust (and they have more difficulty earning
a living) when you download music illegally.
|
| Research |
People trust that lab experiments are run properly and that the data is not altered
(including suppression of some data) to make the results look better. Altering data can lead
to the use of drugs in ways that harm or even kill people.
|
| Stocks |
You buy stocks in a company, trusting that its reports
are accurate and that its employees are honest. The Enron debacle (and later
subprime mortgage meltdown) shows how bad things can become when that trust is broken.
In these cases, the broken trust ruined the lives of many people.
|
| Politics |
We want to trust our leaders. When they act in
ways that seem to benefit them and their friends rather than our
society as a whole, cynicism sets in and we lose faith in them and
in our system of governing. Too often, the parties in Congress
appear to be more interested in preserving their own self-interest
than in working together for society.
|
| Email |
When the internet started, everyone trusted everyone else. No one would spam, and if they did,
they were taken to task. But, as the internet grew, trust was severely violated, and now, it is
estimated that 90% of all email is spam. This is a huge drain on resources. Some spam is fairly
innocent (but it is still spam). The more malicious kind preys on people, especially the
children and the elderly.
|
Cheating destroys the respect others have for you when they find out
that you cheated. More importantly, cheating, starting on a small scale,
can continue to grow, leading to cheating on a large scale later on.
Cheating destroys your character. It can lessen what you think of yourself
and ruin your self-confidence. It can ruin your life. While cheating
may seem to help in the short run, in the long run it can lead to disaster.
There is another view of cheating. Cheating is a crime against the honest students. It is a way
to screw your classmates, the people who think you are their friend. You cheat, your grade goes up,
and maybe the curve changes to your benefit and their detriment. Do you want to do that to friends?
Cornell Code of Academic Integrity
Cornell University has a
Code of Academic Integrity, which
explains clearly what is academic cheating and what is not. The following website explains the academic
integrity procedures from the standpoint of the student, the instructor, and the members of an
Academic Integrity Hearing Board; spend some time now, looking at it:
http://www.theuniversityfaculty.cornell.edu/AcadInteg/
Violations of the Cornell University Code of Academic Integrity occurring
in Computer Science courses are taken seriously by the Computer
Science faculty. Therefore, it is necessary to impress upon students
the gravity of violations of the Code. The following are excerpts from
a longer version of the Cornell University Code of Academic Integrity.
The exclusion of any part does not excuse ignorance of the Code.
Principle
Absolute integrity is expected of every Cornell student in all academic undertakings.
A person must in no way misrepresent their work fraudulently, unfairly advance their
academic status, or be a party to another person's failure to maintain academic integrity.
The maintenance of an atmosphere of academic honor and the fulfillment of the provisions
of this Code are the responsibilities of the students and faculty of
Cornell University. Therefore, all students and faculty members shall
refrain from any action that would violate the basic principles of this
Code.
General responsibilities
A student assumes responsibility for the content and integrity of the academic work he/she
submits, such as papers, examinations, or reports. A student shall be guilty of violating
the Code and subject to proceedings under it if they:
- knowingly represents the work of others as their own.
- uses or obtains unauthorized assistance in any academic work.
- gives fraudulent assistance to another student.
- fabricates data in support of laboratory or field work.
- forges a signature to certify completion or approval of a course assignment.
- in any other manner violates the principle of absolute integrity.
Specific Issues in CS 1110
Note: "You" in the following statements refers to "you and your partner",
if you are allowed to work with a partner.
What may you not do?
- For an assignment: You may not have or look at (or listen to the reading of, etc.) the code of another student in the course.
- For an assignment: You may not have or look at the code of a student for a similar assignment in a previous version of this course.
- For an assignment: You may not show (or read aloud to, or email, etc.) your code to another student in the course.
- You may not remove your partner's name from an assignment unless you do not use each other's work.
We specify assignments above because lab sessions only, you are allowed to give fellow students help on that session's lab only, as long as you also help the other student understand what is going on and don't just do the work for them.
Who performs the work?
-
You must submit only work you did. Using a computer does not modify the standards of academic
integrity stipulated in the Cornell University code of conduct.
-
You may discuss work with other students. However, cooperation should
never involve other students possessing a copy of all, or a portion
of, your work regardless of format. Courtesy and academic integrity also suggests that you note in a comment who you discussed ideas with, if this discussion helped you. (It is OK to omit mention of course staff, given the class setting.)
-
You cannot remove your partner's name from an assignment unless you do not use each other's work.
What do you submit?
- The programs that you submit must generate the entire output you submit in your assignments.
- You cannot submit more than one assignment if you have worked with a partner.
-
You may not submit answers using someone else's iclicker. Each student should have their own
iclicker and should use only their own.
Can I use someone else's iclicker?
-
Each student should have their own iclicker. To use someone elses's during lectures,
for any reason, is a violation of academic integrity.
What means do we use to catch violators?
-
We use Moss, which was developed by a Cornell PhD. We give the Moss web-based software a
directory containing all the submissions and another file containing the skeleton we gave
you for that assignment. Moss returns a list of pairs of submissions, ranked by the
percentage of similar lines and showing exactly where the similarities are. Changing
variable names does not help. Take a look at it here:
http://theory.stanford.edu/~aiken/moss/.
What are the penalties?
- We assign penalties on a case-by-case basis.
- We hold both you and your partner responsible in case of a violation.
- We may give you a zero on the assignment, lower your grade, fail you in CS 1110,
request a Cornell University disciplinary action like suspension for a semester
and a permanent mark on your transcript.
Who should you contact?
- Contact a member of the course staff immediately if you suspect a Code violation.
|