++++++++START OF REVIEW FORM:         DO NOT DELETE THIS LINE++++++++

-------------------
ACL 2002 Review Form
-------------------

Paper ID#:
Title:


Please rate the paper on the 8 dimensions listed below, according to the
proposed scale running from 1 to 5, where 1 means "poor" and 5 means
"excellent". Please use only the listed numbers.

Your comments on the paper should be reported in the section for the
Program Committee and in the section for the Authors.  Please provide
any comments you think appropriate to help the Program Committee in
making their final decisions; and, especially important, please provide
comments to assist the authors in improving the quality of their final
paper.  Please try to avoid saying anything in the comments to the
author that assumes your recommendation regarding acceptance or
rejection will be followed, since the final decision depends on other
factors, and in particular the other reviews.

Please return the ENTIRE review form:  the "Do not delete" lines are
there to make it possible to semi-automate the handling of the
reviews.

PLEASE SEND THIS FORM TO YOUR AREA SUBCOMMITTEE CHAIR BY March 12, 2002.

--------
Appropriateness: Does the paper fit in ACL-02
        5: Definitely
        4: Probably
        3: Uncertain
        2: Probably not
        1: Certainly not

My vote:


Correctness: Does the paper appear to be flawed technically and/or
                methodologically?
        5: Impeccable
        4: The paper is OK
        3: Only trivial flaws
        2: Minor flaws that must be corrected
        1: Major flaws that make the paper unsound/inconsistent

My vote:

(Optional): Did you (thoroughly,quickly,not) check the technical
                details? (choose one)


Implications: How important is the work?
        5: Will change the future
        4: People will read and cite this paper
        3: Restricted interest
        2: Not of compelling interest
        1: Will have no impact on the field

My vote:


Originality: How novel is the approach?
        5: A radically new approach
        4: An innovative use
        3: A new application of well known techniques
        2: Yet another application of well worn techniques
        1: Entirely derivative

My vote:


Empirical Grounding: Does this paper contain information about evaluation?
        5: Excellent evaluation
        4: Good evaluation
        3: Some evaluation
        2: Evaluation is weak
        1: Should have contained some evaluation, but it didn't;
           or it did but the evaluation was bogus
      N/A: Does not apply

My vote:


Clarity: Is it clear what was done?
        5: Presentation is very clear
        4: Difficult, but understandable
        3: Some parts were not clear to me
        2: Most of the paper is unclear
        1: Presentation is very confusing

My vote:


References: Is the bibliography relevant and exhaustive?
        5: Thorough
        4: Pretty good, but a few missing
        3: Some citations, but some missing
        2: Scrappy citations; a lot missing
        1: Virtually no relevant references cited

My vote:


Out or In: Should the paper be rejected or accepted?
        5: I would fight to have this paper accepted
        4: I would like this paper accepted
        3: I am undecided
        2: I would like this paper rejected
        1: I would fight to have this paper rejected

My vote:

Best Paper: Should the paper be considered for the Best Paper Award (yes/no)?

My vote:


Please rate your confidence in the domain of this paper
(1 = non-expert; 5 = expert).

Confidence in domain:



--------END OF EVALUATION SECTION:       DO NOT DELETE THIS LINE--------

++++++++START OF COMMENTS TO COMMITTEE:  DO NOT DELETE THIS LINE++++++++

Comments to the Program Committee:

Paper ID#:

[Insert comments to replace this line.]

--------END OF COMMENTS TO COMMITTEE:    DO NOT DELETE THIS LINE--------

++++++++START OF COMMENTS TO AUTHOR:     DO NOT DELETE THIS LINE++++++++

Comments to the Author:

Paper ID#:

[Insert comments to replace this line.]

--------END OF REVIEW FORM:              DO NOT DELETE THIS LINE--------