GLENDALE, Ariz. — The seconds ticked off late in the fourth quarter Sunday, and how familiar it must have all seemed to Bill Belichick, to Tom Brady, to the New England Patriots and their fans wondering why, oh why, was this happening again.
In their last two Super Bowls, the Patriots had lost in improbable fashion, last-minute defeats fueled by ridiculous passes and absurd catches, and now came the Seattle Seahawks, driving to the New England 1-yard line.
In a frantic finish, and after a dose of karmic payback, the Patriots survived. It was New England that became a team for the ages, not Seattle, winning its fourth Super Bowl title, 28-24, when Malcolm Butler intercepted Russell Wilson’s pass in the end zone with 26 seconds remaining.
“We’ve had some great teams that haven’t won it and I think you’ve got to just enjoy the moment,” Brady said. “We’ve been on the other end of this twice now.”
Butler’s catch had the same nauseating effect on the Seahawks and their supporters as David Tyree’s helmet catch here seven years ago or Mario Manningham’s sideline grab three years ago did on the Patriots, who lost those Super Bowls to the Giants by a total of 7 points.
It spoiled the Seahawks’ repeat bid, denying them of dynasty status, and returned one of the league’s most successful franchises to glory. And it came on a play call whose merits will be debated in barrooms and boardrooms in the Pacific Northwest for years to come.
Instead of handing the ball off a second straight play to Marshawn Lynch, their bruising running back who had already scored a touchdown, the Seahawks on second down elected to pass. Coach Pete Carroll accepted responsibility, but in the chaos afterward there seemed confusion.
When asked whose decision it was, Wilson deflected the question. The offensive coordinator, Darrell Bevell, said he was comfortable with the choice but, considering the result, he would have liked to have called something different.
“We were on the precipice of another championship,” Carroll said. “Nobody to blame but me.”
In toppling Seattle, New England became the first champion to overcome a 10-point deficit in the fourth quarter, a development that was remarkable and disorienting all at once. As many comebacks as Brady has orchestrated over his sparkling career, this one has to rank among the most special.
Because it came against the swaggering Seahawks, who boasted the N.F.L.’s best defense and would tell anyone who asked as much. Because in its last eight games, all victories, Seattle had outscored its opponents by 83-13 in the fourth quarter and overtime — and by 130-26 after halftime — in a stretch encompassing its stunner two weeks ago in the N.F.C. championship.
Confronted with daunting circumstances, a 24-14 deficit with 12 minutes 10 seconds left, Brady led the Patriots to touchdowns on consecutive drives. The second provided the margin of victory, with Brady completing all eight passes, including a 3-yard toss to Julian Edelman, who had nine receptions for a team-high 109 yards.
“Considering the fact that I almost had two heart attacks,” said Edelman, still wearing his grass-stained jersey, “it was great.”
So it was, all across the Patriots’ empire Sunday night and, particularly, in all corners of University of Phoenix Stadium. Rob Gronkowski cut short an interview because he said he needed to go celebrate. Confetti cascaded from above. In the interview area, Darrelle Revis was chatting with two reporters from Japan, one of whom was wearing a pink cowboy hat. One asked Revis about the victory party.
“It’s already begun,” Revis said. “But you want to come? You can come. But you have to bring the hat.” Then the reporter let Revis put it on.
Although they were asked, and although they would not say, the Patriots said they derived no additional satisfaction — not in their return to the stadium where they were denied perfection seven years ago, not after enduring scrutiny, their image stained, all because of footballs that may or may not have been intentionally deflated.
For them, for Belichick and for Brady and for defenders everywhere of the Patriot Way, validation is measured by Super Bowls, and now they have another.
Before the playoffs started, Wilson and Brady sent emails to a mutual friend. Each quarterback predicted this Super Bowl matchup, and their telepathy made sense: finishing his third season, Wilson is hewing to the Brady career arc: midround draft pick, immediate success as a starter, a title by age 25.
The year after Brady won his first championship, New England did not even reach the playoffs, let alone return to the Super Bowl as Wilson did. Wilson had won his first 10 games against Super Bowl-winning quarterbacks, but Brady, even throwing two interceptions, dazzled, completing 37 of 50 passes for 328 yards and firing touchdowns to four receivers in winning his third Most Valuable Player award. He joined Joe Montana, his boyhood idol, and Terry Bradshaw as the only quarterbacks to win four championships, all of Brady’s coming with Belichick.
“I’m a big Joe Montana fan — I love him to death, I thought he was the best and everything,” Edelman said, but, “Tom Brady came out here, he’s been to six Super Bowls, he’s won four with the salary cap. It’s hard to argue against that.”
All week the Seahawks treated queries about Brady’s brilliance and LeGarrette Blount’s brawn and Gronkowski’s gronkness, about the Patriots’ wacky receiver-ineligible formations and chameleonic offense — 40 rushes one game, 14 the next — and flicked them away like cigarette ash. Not out of arrogance, or disrespect, but the declaration, as stated earlier in the week by linebacker Bobby Wagner that “we do what we do and we do it very good.”
Confusing offenses is not the Seahawks’ style. They just line up in their three-deep coverage, with their thumping secondary, and try to impose their will. Usually successful, the Seahawks were not in the first half. Countering Seattle’s pass-rush, the Patriots ran quick passes, screens and pick plays, and they ran them so well that on their second possession Brady guided New England to the Seattle 10, on a drive that consumed nearly eight minutes.
Chased by Michael Bennett from the left side, Brady made a miserable red-zone decision — throwing nowhere near a receiver, and right into the hands of Jeremy Lane at the goal line. The interception prevented one touchdown, but it indirectly produced another.
On his return, Lane, the Seahawks’ nickel cornerback, sustained an arm injury. Tharold Simon replaced him, and on the Patriots’ next possession Brady exposed him. First with a 24-yard pass to Edelman, zipping across the middle, and then, two plays later, with a perfect slant to Brandon LaFell, whose 11-yard touchdown put New England ahead, 7-0.
For the Seahawks, their offensive malaise — three series, one first down — evoked the first 58 minutes of their last game, the N.F.C. championship victory against the Packers. Nothing Seattle tried, from Lynch’s interior running to dropbacks by Wilson that were thwarted by the Patriots’ superb downfield coverage, seemed to work.
Until Wilson found a matchup he liked and exploited it, connecting deep down the right sideline with Chris Matthews, whose onside kick recovery two weeks ago proved he had excellent hands. Matthews reached over Kyle Arrington and fell backward while hauling in his first career catch, a 44-yarder that set up Lynch’s 3-yard touchdown run with 2:16 left in the first half.
That was far too much time on the clock for Brady, who dissected the Seahawks as if slowly pulling off a Band-Aid — with short passes to Shane Vereen — before yanking it off with a 22-yard touchdown fade to Gronkowski with 31 seconds remaining.
But that was also far too much time for Wilson, who has developed a reputation for clutch passing himself. He drove the Seahawks 80 yards in 29 seconds, a series keyed by a 23-yard pass to Ricardo Lockette and 10-yard personal foul on Arrington. With the ball at the New England 11 and six seconds left before halftime, Carroll had a choice: attempt a field goal or run one final play.
Nothing about the Seahawks’ aggressive personality suggested they would play it safe, and Wilson whipped a pass on the outside to the 6-foot-5 Matthews, who exploited his 6-inch height advantage over Logan Ryan, for an 11-yard touchdown that evened the score at 14-14 heading into halftime.
The Seahawks, masters of the second half and the fourth quarter, were in the middle of reeling off 17 straight points. They were in control until they were not — a feeling New England knew all too well, and returned when Seattle took over with 2:02 to play at its own 20.
Three plays after Wilson opened the drive by throwing a 31-yard pass to Lynch down the left sideline, Jermaine Kearse made a catch to rival Tyree’s on this same field in 2008 — defended by Butler, Kearse had the ball bounce off both thighs and his lower arm before he corralled it at the New England 5.
“I didn’t have any doubt,” receiver Doug Baldwin said. “At that time, you didn’t think there was anyone on the sideline who didn’t think we’d score.”
After a 4-yard run by Lynch, the Seahawks lined up in a three-receiver set. Based on the formation, Butler said he recognized before the snap that Seattle was running a play intended to beat man-to-man coverage. It forced the cornerbacks to line up tight, Butler said.
As Carroll explained it, he did not want to waste a running play against New England’s goal-line defense — he wanted to save that for third and fourth downs, if necessary.
Split out wide were Kearse and Lockette, who stood a few yards behind him and a step to his right. Even though Wilson’s head was not moving, Butler read his eyes, which were scanning in that direction.
The play was designed, Carroll said, for Kearse to shield his defender, allowing the trailing receiver, Lockette, to pop open.
“When they made the call, I didn’t question it,” said Wilson, who finished 12 of 21 for 247 yards. He added: “We thought we had them. I thought it was going to be a touchdown when I threw it. When I let it go, I thought it was going to be game over.”
It was — just not as Wilson expected.
“It’s going to kill me,” Seattle linebacker Bruce Irvin said. “I think I’m about to just go lock myself in my room for about two weeks. This one hurt because we had it. We had it.”
The Seahawks will recover. They are too young, too resilient and too talented. But they also lost in perhaps the cruelest way possible, to a team that once specialized in crushing defeats but no more.
The Patriots are winners again. The Patriots are Super Bowl champions.
689 Comments
Readers shared their thoughts on this article.
The comments section is closed. To send a letter to the editor, write to letters@nytimes.com.
ross
Vermont 7 days agoOh my, I need to spill a Coke on my computer and get rid of all the angry comments. Go Pats.
Another Joe
Maine 7 days agoI'm a happy Pats' fan, but I do feel like people are giving too much criticism to Seattle's last play call.
Look, everyone in the entire world knew that Lynch was going to get the ball. Everyone. And the Pats had stopped him several times.
So, why not do what no one in the entire world expects -- a quick pass just over the goal line? If it worked, Pete Carroll would be a football genius. If it went incomplete, now you have the Pats wondering if you'll do it again or go with Lynch, and slow the defenders a half-step, which is all Lynch would need.
But we're all geniuses in hindsight, right?
BTW, to all you Patriot haters: Do you know who said, "Winning isn't everything, it's the only thing"?
Hint: His name is on the trophy the Patriots just won.
TR
Wall 7 days agoThree things can happen when you throw the football and two of them are bad. An absolutely ridiculous play call in that situation, and the result was, statistically speaking, predictable.
Too bad for Seattle, and New England gets the win. And the chorus of "what if's" will be loud and resounding. In Seattle, anyway.
michjas
Phoenix 7 days agoMy big question is where Wilson goes from here. He was mediocre tonight. This will be a true test of his character. He'll probably land on his feet. But mark my words, the critics won't give him as much time as he deserves if he falters. Brady's two Super Bowl losses weighed on him for years. Now, they'll proclaim him the best ever. The critics are fickle. They expect the impossible. Wilson could be on the hot seat before long. Everyone loves a winner. Not so much second place.
Kona030
HNL 7 days agoThe thing is, if Seattle gives the ball to Lynch, the Patriots probably would have had to LET him score, so as to be able to get the ball back and give Brady 50 seconds or so to go length of the field...
Shows how difficult it really is to win a championship (in any sport), so many things can happen, momentum can shift so quickly, etc....The drama of sports, it beats the drama of most movies and TV shows...
Seatlle had given up 13 pts in last 8 games in the 4th quarter, today 14...
michjas
Phoenix 7 days agoI'm a Pats fan. Their time of possession dominance in the first half spoke loud to me. So did the fact that Seattle scored 2 TD's off of turnovers. When the Pats fell behind by 10, I expected them to lose. But they hadn't been outplayed at that point. So 10 down was bad, but not over. In the end, I thought it was a toss-up. The freak catch sealed a Pats loss. The interception sealed a victory. I'd give the first half to the Pats and the second half to the Hawks. And I'd attribute the Pats victory to that one play, which could have gone either way.
Invidium
CA 7 days agoThis is a perfect example of a classic mistake that spectators make: judging a coach by an outcome, which is out of a coach's control, rather than by a decision, which is in a coach's control.
Pete Carroll decision was the correct one for a very simple reason: TIME.
After Kearse's miracle catch, Seattle had 1:06 remaining with two timeouts. Lynch's run to the 1-yard line forced them to burn a second timeout, leaving Seattle with only one timeout remaining and less than a minute to play.
So suppose you've got three downs, one timeout, less than a minute, and one yard to deal with for the championship. The question that goes through your mind should be, "What happens if we run on second down and get stuffed?" There are two answers: (1) you burn about 15 seconds to hurry-up to your next play, which, if unsuccessful, leads to you using your last timeout before your last shot at the championship. (2) You burn your timeout after the run on second down and then are forced to hurry-up to fourth down if the third down play doesn't convert. Either way, you don't have an opportunity to plan for one of those downs.
Carroll claims that the matchup of Lynch against the New England goal line defense would probably have led to their RB getting stuffed, which means Seattle has to deal with all of the above. If that's true, then he made the correct DECISION, which was to pass. If it converts, great. If it doesn't, then the clock is stopped, and you have time to plan the last two downs.
bbpi4
New York, NY 6 days agoIn Carroll's defense, I've seen the Seahawks complete those short slant passes near the goal line all season. I'm sure he regrets it now - but had it worked (and it was close) he'd have been sung a genius by some for having surprised the Patriot defenders.
Manuel
Clovis, CA 6 days agoI love all these back and forth comments. I started out watching the game, not caring about which side won, only hoping for a good game. I got my wish and then some. I also ended up rooting for Brady. He's a class act and I wanted him up there with Montana and Bradshaw.
soxared04/07/13
Crete, Illinois 6 days agoA native Bostonian joyfully celebrates the Patriots' fourth Super Bowl title and vindication of Coach Bill Belichick and quarterback Tom Brady. Multiple subtexts abound. XLIX was perhaps the finest of all. The NFL endured a horrendous year from a public relations standpoint. The Patriots are a team that countless millions of fans despise. In the glow of my joy, two things stand out: 1. Richard Sherman's great show of sportsmanship to nemesis to Tom Brady at the end, and 2. Pete Carroll's play call just moments before. I hope Seahawks fans will appreciate Coach Carroll 's tremendous contribution to that franchise. His gamble failed; that does not make him an evil man. There was a flaw in the plan that he could not foresee. He should not be crucified. I truly hope that Seattle will clutch him to its breast with, as William Shakespeare wrote, "hoops of steel."
689 Comments
Readers shared their thoughts on this article.
The comments section is closed. To send a letter to the editor, write to letters@nytimes.com.